The Best Dog Collars of 2024

The top dog by far among the classic nylon collars we found, the Max and Neo is fitted with beautiful, heavy-duty gunmetal hardware, including a securely locking buckle instead of a cheap plastic clasp.

The one-inch wide nylon is forged into a double thick, four-millimeter layer, which not only improves durability, but greatly increases comfort; it won’t scratch, dig or chafe into the dog’s neck. The eyelets are also reinforced with metal (all in all, upping its chances of withstanding regular trips through the washing machine), and while traditional in design, a number of smart and thoughtful touches make this collar far from basic.

This collar has reflective stitching for night walks, and a hole in the buckle specifically for attaching tags.

We’re also sweet on Max and Neo as a company, since they donate collars to rescue organizations for each one they sell.

Our top pick amongst leather collars, Perri’s model is made in the U.S. by Amish craftsman, from soft and supple lambskin that’s lined with padding for superior comfort.

The stainless steel hardware includes a securely latching buckle, and is sturdy without being too bulky or heavy.

This leather padded collar is a bit more finicky to maintain, as it can only be hand washed. As with most leather collars, there’s a smaller range of colors to choose from (although the available two-toned options are very chic).

Leather collars can be stiff, at least on the outset, so we liked the flexibility of the Aolove. The trade-off is that it’s a bit thinner than the other leather models we tested, with less padding, although it’s still considerably more comfortable than your basic nylon collar.

The gold-plated hardware looks fashionable and feels durable, but a bit less so than the Perri’s, which is why it just got edged out. Still, this is a good budget pick if you’re looking for one made from leather.

We like that this martingale is made in the U.S., and has reflective stitching. When sized and used appropriately, it can fit well—especially if you go for the custom option, which allows you to enter the exact size of your dog’s neck.

But even though it claims to be made to military specs for extra strength and durability, we found the nylon webbing to be way too thin and very scratchy, which is undoubtedly uncomfortable for a dog. This model is also considerably more expensive than our top martingale pick.

While this is a good pick for dogs that put their collars through heavy wear and tear, we wouldn’t describe it as a comfort collar and you could do better with others on our list.

If you want to go hog wild with customization, by adding your pet’s name and phone number, and choosing amongst colors, then this is for you.

But if you prioritize function over form, you’ll quickly identify the issues—the stiff, plastic hardware is difficult to adjust for a comfortable and secure fit. It also uses a clasp instead of a buckle, which is always a safety concern.

This is one of the least expensive options on our list, but we simply don’t think the price differential is enough to go with such a throwaway collar. Sure, it comes in tons of jazzy colors, but the nylon webbing is super thin with unfinished edges, making it very scratchy and prone to cutting into the neck.

Instead of a buckle, it has a flimsy plastic clasp that could easily unlatch. It’s also not built to stand up to too many passes in the washing machine, so this is the kind of collar that will invariably build up a stink before too long.